This is my first tubbing mascara so wasn’t sure what to expect. It does stay put the entire day and there is no under eye smudging even after 12 hours. To remove it you need to rub (a lot!) your eyelashes with warm water. Overall it’s a good mascara but I hate rubbing my eyes to remove it.

This mascara is the only mascara that I’ll use now , it doesn’t smudge , and comes off with warm water and makes lashes look amazing

This is a good mascara, comes off easily with warm water. I was just hoping it would be add more lenght to my lashes. 

Read some good and bad reviews about this mascara and never normally pay this sort of price but with older thinning lashes and constantly watering eyes, found this definitely defined my thinning lashes and stayed on all day with no smudging.

Disappointed with this mascara. Was expecting something better than the usual Clinique high impact mascara, which is good but I thought I give this a try for a change. I found it very gluey to put on and even worse to get off - felt like waterproof mascara. I won't be buying again.