This mascara is usually great when I buy direct from Eyeko, but I think this was an old product. I bought it for my holiday and have found it is clumpy and almost unusable. It’s so disappointing as I can’t get another waterproof one while I’m away. 

Other reviews are saying exactly the same thing and they are right. This mascara arrived so dried out that the wand became stuck inside and impossible to even take out. I can't believe LF have been notified of this a long time ago (see previous review from March 2022, this review is from August 2023) and have continued to sell this batch of product. It's very telling of how good their quality control is. Such a shame as I think this mascara is great and have been using it for a long time. My last ever order from here, they are being fussy about sending a refund even after I sent them pictures of bone dry mascara. Uninstalling app imediately.

I have been using Eyeko Sport Mascara since it’s conception, and like many of us who know and love this brand in the last few months we have struggled to get the mascara from anywhere as stocks are down.  Imagine my relief and joy when I found them on LF albeit just ten travel size. Without hesitation I bought 3.  Lo and behold, 2 of them were very dry and flaky. Presumably these may be out of date or just stored very badly (fibre mascaras need great care, perhaps a quality LF do not understand). Anyway, this was not the usual quality of Eyeko sport mascaras.  In desperation for using my beloved brand, I did what any mascara expert does I.E. submerge sealed tube into warm water for 15 minutes. That seemed to loosen the formula as I would expect.  Nonetheless, I realised for a brand new item I should not have to do this and decided to return bowing never to use LF again whose return policy creates further barriers.  The other reviewers are right, there is something very wrong with these items and I can assure you it’s not of the usual Eyeko quality therefore I will be letting Eyeko know of this too.  Very disappointed, dissatisfied, and ultimately disgusted by the whole experience!

This mascara gives my lashes great lift, length and separation. It also does not seem to budge with moisture. However, I find it flakes off into my eyes every time I wear it, which leads me to not use it anymore.

I bought this to try Eyeko as I had read good feedback on their mascaras. This mascara doesn't do much for my lashes. The texture is kind of thick when applying, maybe this is a similar issue to other reports of it seeming dried out. I have to apply a lot to get any noticeable volumisisng effect. It does stay on most of the day but with summer allergy eyes that run (the reason I bought this waterproof formula) it doesn't really last until the night time and I notice when takin goff my makeup at night that it is a bit of a smudged mess. Disappointing.