I am an avid Urban Decay eyeliner user have been for 10+ years. I decided to try this and have to say love it. So soft going on and stays put even when my eyes water with allergies (it is the season). Will definitely alternate between this and Urban Decay on a daily basis.

I now buy my 8PM eyeliner from EBAY because it is so much cheaper and SAVES PLASTIC. This item should be available without the sharpener for those of us who already have the sharpener from previous buys. I LOVE this product but we need more value and sustainability please bare minerals

Would be great eyeliner - easy to apply and stays on all day, no smudge and waterproof, unfortunately left me with streaming, red and itchy eyes and nose - disappointing for a hypo-allergenic make up line :-( Back to BadGal it is - can't beat it...

I love this pencil named in Midnight black , it's a dark deep black shade. It's like a gel liquid liner, glides on very easy, and it has really long lasting formula. It's worth to fix with eyeshadow or powder either, because I've noticed that it smudge on waterline. I'm satisfied with this.

This is by far my favourite eyeliner ever! It has such a smooth and creamy application there is no longer the need to hold your eyelid tightly when applying. I seriously rate this eyeliner I also like the fact you have to sharpen it but around 1/2 a twist or less gets it back up to the required sharpness to apply a thin line to the eye which is extremely useful as it means there is hardly any wastage of the product! Best money I've spent on make up for a long time!