Disappointingly I think the brown has been discontinued.  This is a shame as brown is a much warmer colour for my complexion than black that can look harsh.    This is a fairly good mascara and when used with the tinted primer can give that wow factor, but works fine on its own too.    I have noticed some smudging on occasion but possibly I had a ferocious eye rub!

It’s great to find a good quality mascara in brown. My mother finds black to harsh and absolutely loves this mascara she said it doesn’t smudge or clump and elongates her natural lashes. Will definitely purchase again 

I never got on with black mascara as, even if it claimed to be smudge proof, I would always end up with panda eyes. This mascara is lighter but still great at boosting volume without creating smudge-eye.

I had really high hopes for this mascara but unfortunately I just find it incredibly tacky and clumpy. Quite a disappointment given the price, I probably won’t repurchase 

I love this mascara! I usually buy it in black but thought I would try the brown to use for a more natural look and it does just that. My lashes look super long and separated.