I have fairly small eyes and oily skin so with both these in mind, this mascara is great! Brush allows precise easy application and did not smudge creating panda eyes like most mascaras...I would recommend !

Really good waterproof mascara which doesn't leave panda eyes. Would recommend

My go to mascara. The only mascara I've ever tried in my life that doesn't slowly give me worse and worse panda eyes throughout the day. I'm not sure if it's the shape of my face or what, but every other mascara on the market give my a smudged line beneath my eyes after two hours of wear. This is the only one I've found that actually does what it says on the bottle - zero smudge!! - Something I'm beginning to realise with all Estee Lauder products - they actually do what they say they do!! Could fan, volumise and lift better is my only gripe.