This is so nice, and does what it needs to do without the hefty price tag like some! 

Very much just tinted sugar in a pot. Difficult to scoop out. The tint means that you have to be careful applying it or you end up with red everywhere. Half of it usually falls down the sink as its very dry and just falls off. Also coarse and not good for sensitive skin

does the job but does stain red so you have to really scrub it off

This is a good product and to be honest as good as others I've tried. I do find it can stain my skin a little - it washes off, but I only use at bed time because of this.

Love this scrub so much. Not only did it make my lip super soft, but it also smells amazing.