Lowest rating I have given on here. It is most definitely waterproof I can confirm but it seems a bit dry and I always get bits in my eyes. I love the non waterproof Mac Stack mascara though and will repurchase. This is I’m afraid I won’t. 

Nothing compares the the max stacks, I bought the waterproof one just so I could wear it on holiday. Flakes ever so slightly in the pool/water slides but no panda eyes or smudges at all 

Wish I was a fan of this but I'm just not. You need more than one coat and as soon as you apply it weighs your lashes down and goes clumpy. Yes it does give a lot of volume but it's really wet for a waterproof mascara and I would not purchase again

This is a fab waterproof mascara! I don’t normally buy MAC mascaras but I was thoroughly impressed with it. It stayed on in water and does not smudge. It doesn’t clump and leaves lashes looking lovely and nicely separated. Would highly recommend.

Good mascara, first time trying in waterproof. Wish I’d waited,  personally don’t get on with waterproof mascara.  Much prefer original.