I was so pleased by the non waterproof one! The way it applies and keeps the ladhes! I needed a waterproof and this is Just perfect. 

I usually have my go to mascara but a friend who is a makeup artist used this on me and I loved the look ( for a very small Price) the only reason I did not give 5 stars is that it tends to smudge because my lashes are so long on my eyes so it’s not always a great look