It’s really black, but the packaging broke after few uses and I had to throw it away

It already dried up when it arrived so I can’t say if it’s good or bad. I guess it’s bad as it dried even before first use!

Great liner, bought is as a gift for me teenage daughter and she was very happy with it.  

This one is extreme black! I love the pigment payoff and it doesn’t skip on the eyelid. It’s not a complete matte finish, I’d say it’s in between matte and satin but it lasts all day and doesn’t smudge 

I can happily report this gives a nice deep black finish that stays put.