I saw this recommended a few years ago and so pleased I got it, as not heavily advertised. It’s really good and although not waterproof is definitely smudge proof so doesn’t budge all day. Must be my 4th or 5th purchase. 

Not clumpy at all. Lashes look Lovely and long.

Probably one of the worst mascara I’ve tried. Smudges and leaves mascara dots on your eye lids. Also makes your lashes look like spider legs. Terrible 

I really like the wand with this mascara plus it doesn’t smudge and stays looking good all day 

Unfortunately didn’t live up to the previous reviews I read on this, for me personally it’s not buildable amd my lashes limp not long after applying.