Such a beautiful product. Easy to apply, glides on, strong with couleur, doesn’t smudge when you want it to be bold. Only issue I have found is sharpening it needs a really good decent sharpener 

Thought it’s a great pencil and easy to use. Lasts a long time and doesn’t really smudge so happy buyer here! 

It’s just a bit lighter for me than what I was expecting, not a very intense shade of brown on the eyes 

gorgeous colour and formula, super pigmented too!

I've tried several different pencil eyeliners and a kajal crayon and even the ones that promised high staying power bled and smudged so I'd end up with panda eyes after about an hour, even after applying concealer to seal the liner. This pencil though really DOES stay - you can see it's much more solid on first application, though you can still blend it a little on first application. It DID smudge a bit when I was running around and got hot and sweaty and of course when I've fallen asleep, otherwise its staying power is excellent. For the record, I have oily eyelids and my eyes are the smaller, hooded almond shape variety rather than the kind of larger eye that suits a smudged heavily kholed look, so it's not easy for me to find a compatible eyeliner. I've given 4 stars as my only complaint is the colour - I got Killer Queen which is a very red based purple, though if it's blended and mixed slightly with a blue or black liner the red is toned down to a more flattering lavender purple.