I bought the colour Amped after looking for ages for a pigmented eyepencil that I could use in my water line. I have a lot of colours from one specific brand that are good for the first hour or so, but then the colour just fades. So I decided to 'splurge' on this from urban decay and see whether the colour would last longer and whether the pigmentation would really show up in my water line - I have eyeliners from various brands that are either/or not both, so I thought maybe for the price, this would do both and I do love Urban Decay as a brand. The reason I gave it a three was because the colour does last longer than an hour, perhaps three (?), definitely not a full day at work. This would be ok, but the pigmentation is also not very good (at least in my opinion and judging from other brands' eyeliners). Perhaps it is because I got the pink colour, and not a more vibrant one, but I did expect more from UD. However, it does get three stars because if you do a pale pink look and this is actually perfect for it. It also comes off nicely if you use it on your eyelid (still not vibrant, i mean, considering the collection it comes from I expected the colour pay off to be super vibrant).